home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1557>
- <title>
- Nov. 14, 1994: Environment:Animal Genocide Mob Style
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Nov. 14, 1994 How Could She Do It?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- ENVIRONMENT, Page 77
- Animal Genocide, Mob Style
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> A new report says organized crime is muscling in on the illegal
- wildlfe trade
- </p>
- <p>By Michael D. Lemonick--Reported by Andrea Dorfman/New York, Terence Nelan/Moscow and
- Satsuki Oba/Tokyo
- </p>
- <p> In four years of undercover work, Steven Galster has been all
- over the world, from the black markets of Zimbabwe to the back
- alleys of Moscow. Most of the time, he has felt reasonably safe--but not always. "I had one meeting with a Russian gang that
- had been burned before," he says, "and I had a funny feeling
- about it. I was wired up and wearing a hidden camera, but I
- decided to take off the recorder and hide it in my gym bag.
- They frisked me, but it was O.K." It might have easily gone
- otherwise: the people he hung out with were frequently armed
- and very dangerous, as hoods involved in weapons dealing, gambling,
- drug smuggling, money laundering and prostitution usually are.
- </p>
- <p> Galster, however, wasn't especially interested in any of those
- unsavory activities. As a co-director of the San Francisco--based Endangered Species Project, he goes after the illicit
- trade in wildlife. And there is no shortage of work. Unsanctioned
- traffic in animals and animal parts--birds of prey, tiger
- skins, tiger bones and bear gallbladders out of Russia; rhino
- horns and elephant ivory from Africa; whale meat into Japan;
- rare birds and snakes from South America--has more than doubled
- in value since 1989, generating an estimated $6 billion in annual
- revenues. According to Interpol, the international police agency,
- wildlife trafficking is now the second largest form of black-market
- commerce, behind drug smuggling and ahead of arms dealing.
- </p>
- <p> Plenty of laws and international agreements forbid such trade,
- but enforcement ranges from spotty to nonexistent. That's why
- delegates to this week's 126-nation biennial meeting of the
- Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES)
- in Fort Lauderdale will be considering a proposal for a worldwide
- enforcement agency that would pool information from member countries
- and coordinate prosecution efforts.
- </p>
- <p> But as a report being issued this week by Galster's group makes
- disturbingly clear, such an agency could find itself overwhelmed
- as soon as it is created. The reason: not only have small-time
- wildlife smugglers become increasingly organized and professional,
- but--more ominously--traditional organized-crime operations
- have finally awakened to the huge profit potential of wildlife
- smuggling.
- </p>
- <p> In Japan, for example, the 300 or so minke whales killed legally
- each year can't begin to satisfy the demand for whale meat,
- a delicacy that commands about $100 a plate. Customs officials
- frequently seize illegal shipments on the way into the country.
- But plenty slips through, and a recent study published in Science
- suggests that some of it comes from whales that can't be hunted
- legally. Investigators bought whale meat in retail markets all
- over Japan. Using DNA tests, researchers found that some of
- it came from fin whales, humpbacks and other protected species.
- "We were stunned to find humpback being sold in a Hiroshima
- supermarket," says Don White, president of Earthtrust, the Hawaii-based
- group that sponsored the study. "They've been protected since
- 1966."
- </p>
- <p> Less than a week after the Japanese government first learned
- of the study last May, police busted a whale-meat smuggling
- operation in Nagasaki, arresting three men and seizing a Korean
- fishing vessel with 11 tons of undocumented whale meat aboard.
- It turned out to be run by the yakuza, Japan's organized-crime
- syndicate. Last week one of the gangsters involved was sentenced
- to 18 months in prison.
- </p>
- <p> In South America drug cartels have long been involved in the
- animal trade, but until lately it was mostly a way to move their
- primary product. Agents have found cocaine in polar-bear skins
- and live boa constrictors, and heroin packed into a tiger rug's
- skull. "A few years ago, it was cement utility poles stuffed
- with cocaine," says Jorge Picon, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
- Service's senior enforcement agent in Miami. "Now it's wildlife."
- </p>
- <p> Picon and others say that the cartels are now getting into the
- wildlife trade for its own sake--not surprising, considering
- that a single South American parrot, bought from a poacher for
- just a few dollars, can fetch a street price of as much as $40,000
- in the U.S. or Europe. Animals are useful for money laundering
- as well. According to Picon's agency, smugglers frequently trade
- illegal drugs for endangered species, resulting in cashless
- transfers. And an official from Interpol has told TIME that
- the agency is tracking airplanes that fly into Leticia, a port
- in the Colombian Amazon, with cargoes of motorcycles and appliances,
- then fly out with animals obtained in the area. "We suspect,"
- says the official, "that the outgoing planes are loaded with
- cocaine or coca paste along with animals."
- </p>
- <p> It is in Russia, where Galster had his close call, that professional
- criminals have penetrated most deeply into the endangered-species
- business. Mafia groups have moved into Moscow's so-called Bird
- Market, where an enormous variety of exotic animals and endangered-species
- products changes hands. "There are birds from all over the world,"
- says Galster, "as well as chimpanzees and lemurs." Customers
- can also place orders for wild ginseng, walrus ivory, tiger
- furs, sea otters and beluga whales. Some dealers even have price
- lists printed in English.
- </p>
- <p> Supplying this bizarre bazaar, and the export market as well,
- is a nationwide network of loosely affiliated professional gangs,
- supplied by ruthless poachers. Using snowmobiles, helicopters,
- horses and dogs, the poachers have killed half the musk deer
- population in just three years and pushed the Siberian tiger
- to the brink of extinction. As few as 150 of the tigers are
- left.
- </p>
- <p> These are not laid-back crooks. The Russian Environment Ministry's
- antipoaching unit set up a sting in Khabarovsk to trap a known
- mafia member involved in this network, but according to Galster
- the operation went bad. "When the agent went home and opened
- the kitchen door, his apartment blew up," he says. "His wife
- and child were killed, and he's still in the hospital." All
- told, says Deputy Environment Minister Amirkhan Amirkhanov,
- 24 members of the unit have been killed on duty since 1992.
- Both the antipoaching patrols and the customs department are
- severely understaffed, and Russia has just two investigators
- charged with making sure that exotic-animal imports and exports
- to conform to CITES rules.
- </p>
- <p> The rest of the world isn't much better at enforcement. Many
- countries in South America and Asia are short on resources,
- and even in such wealthy nations as Japan and the U.S. authorities
- are overwhelmed. Picon points out that he has only five inspectors
- in Miami--enough to examine 3% of wildlife shipments for contraband.
- </p>
- <p> The CITES conference has dozens of items on its agenda this
- week, most of them concerned with adopting new regulations or
- modifying existing ones. Unless the member nations can find
- a way to make the rules stick, though, they may find that the
- animals they're trying to protect no longer exist.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-